|
The truth is something we shall seldom know, but never stop seeking.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Let’s say it plain and simple: the United States lost its balance, its perspective, on 9-11, 2001 and we have yet to fully regain it. We went way, way overboard in our national reaction to that horrid, scary day and our government, led by Bush, played the fears to the hilt. We have spent, or are spending, about a trillion dollars on the two wars and untold billions in “security” measures which, for the most part, are probably wasted. We have turned our airports into replicas of prison intake centers, we have delayed hundreds of thousands of travelers by closing entire airports at the mildest security breach and we have made the normal act of flying from place to place filled with tensions as flight attendants attempt to act like policemen in the sky. Dozens have been subjected to arrest for the slightest, provocative act or statement when flying.
The question is this: how do we get our balance back? Once you’ve jumped off into the deep end of the pool, with no ladder, how do you climb back out? Once you have assumed that every corner of every building in the Islamic world could be hiding a terrorist, what do you do?
Ted Koppel, the owner of the familiar face that came into several million living rooms five nights a week for 25 years, is out with a commentary today in the WashPost in which he says the US has played right into the hands of the terrorists with our over reaction. That is right, as far as it goes. Koppel is wrong, however, when he ascribes to bin Laden the conclusion that this was all intended, that bin Laden’s plan, from the start, was to provoke the US into a self destructive reaction (that bin Laden would boast that this was his intention long after the fact is not surprising, just a matter of someone who had failed in his master plan trying to adjust to changes along the way.)
The most fanciful, and therefore dangerous, of Koppel’s points starts in a paragraph with this first sentence: “Perhaps bin Laden foresaw some of these outcomes when he launched his 9/11 operation from Taliban-secured bases in Afghanistan.” In this case, Koppel is repeating the mistakes he wishes to attack, those of the American government, in attributing to the terrorists more care, intelligence and outright wisdom than they have ever demonstrated. What makes it dangerous is that we should not base our actions on broad, unproved assumptions about the abilities of alQueda or any other terrorist group. We should judge them only for what they are, not what we imagine they might be.
Other than this and a few other lose ends here and there, Koppel’s point is straight on target. The United States, strapped for funding from taxes from its own base, is spending billions and billions in the name of security, something which can never be fully guaranteed by any plan of action we set in motion. Koppel makes the point, which has been made dozens of times by the TerryReport, that you can never be fully secure so far as terrorism is concerned.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The problem is that we are treating terrorism, and security at airports and other places, as though we can take measures which will, in the main, make us totally secure. We are running very hard, at high cost, in the wrong direction. We are spending vast sums of money and time to do something which cannot be achieved. Instead, we need to face the fact the terrorism is something that cannot easily be defeated nor easily go away, like a persistent, but not widespread, disease.
It should never be forgotten that bin Laden and his immediate followers believed that 9-11 would be not the start of a long war, but the big, final blow against America and its power around the world. Misjudging, horribly, from the examples of Somalia and Lebanon, bin Laden thought he could carry out an attack that would so shock and dishearten America that we would summarily withdraw from “the world stage”. His conclusion was based on self propagandized ignorance, but instead of keeping that in mind, we have, by invading two countries, conspired to put future terrorists on a learning course about America, our methods, our strengths and weaknesses. Looking for a new, lasting enemy in the face of the collapse of the Soviet empire, the US government treated the terrorists as though they were a government, too, complete with intense knowledge of our culture and our military power. This was dead wrong.
|
|
|
|
If the wars and the massive security measures can’t protect us, then what is our government doing? Well, for one thing, it is trying to cover all the bases and make it appear that everything possible is being done. So, why not do it three, four or five times over? A lot of it is just for show, a lot of it arises because the government didn’t know what to do, precisely, so why not go for big targets in a hundred ways? How can you be blamed for anything that happens in the future if you spend hundreds of billions of dollars every year to try to stop it?
The “fight against terrorism” will not be won by spending every cent we have, and all we can borrow, on a multitude of wars, covert actions and endless security measures. It can only be won with calm, well reasoned and, most importantly, restrained leadership. We need to chose our targets more carefully and go after them more intelligently and intensely. The amount of money and effort that is going into the effort now probably helps to ensure its failure. Overkill doesn’t work if you hit the wrong target. At some point, when you can buy anything, you buy too much and start not just buying the same things, but actually creating a structure of self defeat.
To truly understand 9-11, one has to be able to turn it over and look at it not from the panic reaction of Americans but to think of it from the perspective of the Arab and Muslim world. Those attacks could easily be seen as the insane overreaching of a madman who could, in the end, accomplish nothing but heartache. While there is much talk in the west of the “Arab street” version of events, it is important to realize that mass public opinion is only one component there, as it is here. What do the educated elites think of bin Laden? How do governments view his grand “accomplishment”? To the eyes of many, bin Laden has bought nothing but trouble with no prospect of reaching his ultimate goals. Besides, how many people in the middle-east actually share his objectives? Whatever we do, we should not make new converts for him.
Terrorism came to the United States, big time, nine years ago. But, we should always remember that it had hit elsewhere for decades previously. The people and governments in those countries, including a good portion of Europe, learned to live with it without excessive fear and massive spending. What was new about 9-11 is they hit in our capitals of government and finance and did so in a spectacular way. We reacted as if the attacks of 9-11 had no prior antecedents.
In all probability, some form of terrorism, not necessarily from the middle east, will be a feature of our lives for decades to come, probably throughout this century and beyond. The cat is out of the bag. Terrorism, while not effective in a larger sense, is a tool of choice for the disaffected and powerless.
We can never be fully secure, just as we can never fully guarantee we won’t be killed in a traffic crash or something happening in our own houses. We are going to have to learn to live with some elements of terrorism and we have to also learn to be smart enough, careful enough, to defeat it where we can without adding fuel to the fire.
Doug Terry, 9.10.10
|
|
|
CONTACT THE TERRYREPORT
|
|
|
|
HOME PAGE
|
|
|
|
end
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Photography from Guatemala, Maryland, Italy and elsewhere by Doug Terry
|
|
|
|
OCCUPY PROTESTS GO WORLD WIDE. WHAT DOES IT MEAN?
|
|
|
|
CONTACT THE TERRYREPORT
|
|
|
|
LINKS TO ALL TERRYREPORT STORIES ON AIRPORT SCANNERS located here. Includes links to the WashPost series on the same subject.
|
|
|
|
BIKING TRAILS IN THE WASINGTON, DC AREA
|
|
|
|
W WOULD YOU like to support The TerryReport? Over the years, the TerryReport has posted close to 2,000 pages of news, analysis, commentary and information. Help us continue!
|
|
|
|
VISIT DC? AN ESSAY ON WHY EVERY AMERICAN CITIZEN SHOULD VISIT
|
|
|
|
WOULD YOU BUY THIS CAR?
|
|
|
|
IS COLLEGE WORTH IT? SOME COUNTER VIEWS
|
|
|
|
What in the world is this? Now, after being told a thousand times that al Queda and the war on terrorism is the struggle of our century, it looks like the organization is 3/4s or more dead and the rest is dying. DETAILS HERE.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
One of the best, most lucid and well written American history books I have ever read. This is not merely history, it is the story of much of the creation of the American nation as it entered into a long, horrid conflict with the native peoples. Reading this, you will come to understand the battles between Indians and whites with more clarity than ever before. Personalities come alive and vivid writing carries you through. Out in quality paperback now.
|
|
|
|
THE 10TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE TERRORIST ATTACKS
|
|
|
|
LINKS PAGE FOR NEWSPAPERS AND OTHER MAJOR MEDIA OUTLETS
|
|
|
|
|
|